Constitutional political economy by Hayek: The conflict between democracy and liberalism
TERRA ECONOMICUS, 2020, Vol. 18 (no. 3),
This paper analyzes the constitutional political economy of Friedrich von Hayek in the context of the well-known contradiction between democracy and liberalism. It is alleged that Hayek at about the same time as researchers from the school of public choice developed the concept of failures of a democratic state, which remains relevant today. Among such failures are subordination to group interests, excessive redistributive activity (growth of the welfare state), legal positivism as a consequence of the unlimited will of the majority. A draft constitutional structure developed by Hayek is considered, aimed at reducing the influence of electoral democracy in order to preserve a free society. The differences in the approaches of Hayek and theorists of public choice to constitutional construction are especially emphasized. For the former, the constitution (despite accusations of constructivism due to the proposed ideal of the constitutional structure) is still a product of evolution. For the latter, it is the result of rational choice under the famous veil of ignorance. The paper shows that Hayek was one of the first to pay attention to formal and informal institutions (moral principles) and showed the crucial role of the latter to characterize the conflict between democracy and liberalism. At the same time, the role of Hayek is noted as one of the first researchers who drew attention to such important aspects of the institutional theory as a competition of institutions and significant restrictions on the international import of institutions due to the impossibility of constructing informal institutions. The final conclusion of the work is that electoral democracy does not destroy constitutional freedoms only if the latter are firmly rooted in public consciousness. Otherwise, their formal proclamation does not mean their guaranteed existence.
Citation: Zaostrovtsev, A. (2020). Constitutional political economy by Hayek: The conflict between democracy and liberalism. Terra Economicus, 18(3), 18–29. DOI: 10.18522/20736606-2020-18-3-18-29
Keywords: constitution; democracy; liberalism; government failure; welfare state; legal positivism; institutions
JEL codes: B31, B53, D72, K10
- Balcerowicz, L., Radzikowski, M. (2018). The Case for Targeted Criticism of the Welfare State. Cato Journal, 38(1), 1–16.
- Boettke, P. (2018). F.A. Hayek: Economics, Political Economy, and Social Philosophy. London: Palgrave McMillan.
- Brennan, G., Buchanan, J. (2005). The Reason of Rules: Constitutional Political Economy. Saint Petersburg: The School of Economics Institute Publ. (In Russian.)
- Buchanan, J. M. (1997). Collected works. Moscow: Tauras Alpha. (In Russian.)
- Buchanan, J. M. (2004). Politics without romance: A sketch of positive public choice theory and its normative implications, pp. 417–434 / In: A. Zaostrovtsev (ed.) Milestones of Economic Thought. Welfare Economics and Public Choice, vol. 4. Saint Petersburg: The School of Economics Institute Publ. (In Russian.)
- Buchanan, J. M. (1997). Post-Socialist Political Economy: Selected Essays. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar.
- Chetvernin, V. (2014). The concept of law: competing paradigms, pp. 161–205 / In: Capitalism and Freedom: collection of articles. Saint Petersburg: Nestor-istorija Publ. (In Russian.)
- Hayek, F. A. von (2006). Law, Legislation and Freedom: A Contemporary Understanding of Liberal Principles of Justice and Politics. Moscow: IRISEN Publishing House. (In Russian.)
- Hayek, F. A. von (2009). The Fate of Liberalism in the XX Century. Moscow, Chelyabinsk: IRISEN Publishing House, Mysl Publ., Sotsium Publ. (In Russian.)
- Hayek, F. A. von (2018). The Constitution of Liberty. Moscow: Novoe izdatelstvo Publ. (In Russian.)
- Holcombe, R. (2015). Public choice and Austrian economics, pp. 492–508 / In: C.J. Coin, P. Boettke (eds.) The Oxford Handbook of Austrian Economics. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
- Hoppe, H.-H. (1994). F.A. Hayek on government and social evolution: a critique. The Review of Austrian Economics, 7(1), 67–93.
- Jasay de, A. (1994). The cart before the horse: on emergent and constructed orders and their wherewithal, pp. 29–44 / In: C. Frei, R. Nef (eds.) Contending with Hayek. Bern: Peter Lang.
- Kuznetsov Yu. (2019). Universal basic income and the problem of information asymmetry. Economic policy, 14(3), 80–95. (In Russian.)
- Leoni, B. (2008). Freedom and the Law. Moscow: IRISEN Publishing House. (In Russian.)
- Lewis, P. (2015). Hayek: From Economics as Equilibrium Analyses to Economics as Social Theory, pp. 195–223 / In: C.J. Coin, P. Boettke (eds.) The Oxford Handbook of Austrian Economics. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
- Linde, A. N. (2015). Deliberative democracy as a trend in modern theory of democracy: Analysis of the main approaches. Problem Analysis and Public Administration Projection, 8(1), 52–58. (In Russian.)
- Pennington, M. (2015). Constitutional Political Economy and Austrian Economics, pp. 465–491 / In: C.J. Coin, P. Boettke (eds.) The Oxford Handbook of Austrian Economics. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
- Tanner, M. (2015). The Pros and Cons of a Guaranteed National Income. Policy Analysis, 773, May 12.
- Tanner, M., Hughes, Ch. (2015). The Work versus Welfare Trade-Off: Europe. Policy Analysis, 779, August 24.
- Vanberg, V. (1994). Rules and Choice in Economics. London: Routledge.
- Yanovskiy, K. E., Zhavoronkov, S. V. (2017). The few notes on universal suffrage morality. Economic Policy, 12(6), 102–123. (In Russian.)
- Yanovskiy, K., Zhavoronkov, S. (2018). Rule of law and antidiscrimination struggle compatibility: new choice between equality and freedom? (USA case). Social Sciences and Contemporary World, (6), 59–68. (In Russian.)
- Zaostrovtsev, A. (2013). Liberal political economy and philosophy of James Buchanan. Voprosy Ekonomiki, (11), 34–52. (In Russian.)
- Zaostrovtsev, A. (2014). On development and backwardness: How do economists explain history? St. Petersburg: EUPRESS, 248 p. (In Russian.)
- Zaostrovtsev, A. (2018). Economists on the effectiveness of democracy: debate on the turn of the century. Voprosy teoreticheskoy ekonomiki, (2), 8–27. (In Russian.)
Publisher: Southern Federal University
Founder: Southern Federal University
Founder: Southern Federal University