Weimar awaiting «Brumaire»

TERRA ECONOMICUS, , Vol. 13 (no. 2),
p. 6-14

History is an amazing process: like a magic волшебному kaleidoscope, it contrives to construct unique social situations using the same elements, and only humanitarians can reveal their common features. In reality it is not always easy to see «standardized» problems accompanied by the set of «standard solutions» behind different garments of technologies and ideologies of different centuries. Meanwhile, this is the primary goal of social research. Treating the «Weimar economy» as synonymous with the period of nonstabe political and economic equilibrium, the author concludes that usually destruction of this equilibrium implies violation (the coup d’état) – which, while creating an illusion of political stabilization, actually causes the stalemate. The main points of the article – historical antecedents of «Weimar»; Directory – «Weimar» of XVIII century; an economic portrait of the «Weimar Republic»; the mystery of the Weimar system; a methodological key to the mystery of Weimar; social «trap» of Weimar system.

Keywords: «Weimar economy»; transitive period; «The Eighteenth Brumaire» as the classical outcome of «le coup d’état»

  • Drabkin Ya.S. (resp. ed.) (1998). Weimar – Bon. The experience of two German democracies and modern Russia. Series: Russia – Germany – Europe [Opyt dvukh germanskikh demokratiy i sovremennaya Rossiya. Series: Russia – Germany – Europe, issue 4. Moscow: Moscow State University Publ. (In Russian.)
  • Engels F. (1961). Preface to the third German edition of the work by K. Marx, «The Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte» [Predislovie k tretiemu nemetskomu izdaniyu raboty К. Marksa «Vosemnadtsatoe brumera Lui Bonaparta»] / In: Маrx К. and Engels F. Works, vol. 21. Moscow: State publishing house of political literature, 745 p., pp. 258–259. (In Russian.)
  • Germany and facts (undated). 1919–1933: The Weimar Republic [Veimarskaya respublika] (http://www.tatsachen-ueber-deutschland.de/ru/history/main-content-03/1919-1933-the-weimar-republic.html). (In Russian.)
  • Gishchin А.А. (2014). Economic development of the Weimar Republic [Ekonomicheskoe razvitie Veimarskoi respubliki] / In: Kompleev А.V. and Yurina Т.V. (eds.) Russia’s national security and state interests [Natsionalnaya bezopasnost I gosudarstvennye interesy Rossii]. Proceedings of the Conference, Penza, December 17, 2013. Penza: Penza State University, Humanities teaching methods and scientific publishing Center, pp. 29–32. (In Russian.)
  • Lyuks L. (2008). «Weimar Russia?» – notes about a disputed concept [«Veimarskaya Rossiya?» – zametki ob odnom spornom poneyatii. ZN.UA, August 22 (http://gazeta.zn.ua/POLITICS/veymarskaya_rossiya___zametki_ob_odnom_spornom_ponyatii.html). (In Russian.)
  • Magref.ru (2014). The Weimar Republic [Veimarskoe gosudarstvo] (http://magref.ru/veymarskoegosudarstvo/). (In Russian.)
  • Mamedov O.Y. (2011). Why did the Germans voted for Hitler (from the history of economic crimes of the state). Terra Economicus, vol. 9, no. 3. (In Russian.)
  • Marx К. (1957). The Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte. December 1851 – March 1852 [Vosemnadtsatoe brumera Lui Bonaparta. Dekabr 1851 – mart 1852 g.] / In: Маrx К. and Engels F. Works, vol. 8. Moscow: State publishing house of political literature, 705 p., pp. 115–217. (In Russian.)
  • Marx К. (1960). Preface to the second edition of «The Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte» [Predislovie ko vtoromu izdaniyu «Vosemnadtsatoe brumera Lui Bonaparta»] / In: Маrx К. and Engels F. Works, vol. 16. Moscow: State publishing house of political literature, 839 p., pp. 374–376. (In Russian.)
  • Mediasprut (undated). The Weimar Republic [Veimarkskaya respublika] (from Kappler А. (ed.) (1998). Facts about Germany. Frankfurt am Main: Societats-Verlag) (http://www.mediasprut.ru/germ/story/his006.shtml). (In Russian.)
  • Meerson B. and Prokudin D. (1995). The Weimar Republic in Germany: danger of getting massed [Veimarskaya respublika v Germanii: opasnosti massovizatsii]. Znanie-sila, no. 3. (In Russian.)
  • Oleynik A. (2015). The threat of fascism, or Weimar scenario in Russia [Ugroza fashizma ili Veimarskiy stsenariy v Rossii. Vedomosri, February 13 (http://www.vedomosti.ru/opinion/articles/2015/02/13/ugroza-fashizma). (In Russian.)
  • Patrushev А.I. (2004). Germany in XX century [Germaniya v XX veke]. Moscow: Drofa Publ. (In Russian.)
  • Varzonovtsev D. (2007). Resentment «ATTACK» or «Weimar syndrome»: Problem statement [Resentiment «АТАКА» ili «Veimarskiy sindrom»: Postanovla problem]. Political expertise [Politicheskaya ekspertiza: POLITEKS], vol. 3, no. 2, pp. 200–207. (In Russian.)
  • Yakhlov А.V. (2005). Institutional and electoral crisis in the period of economic transition (The Weimar Republic, 1919–1933) [Institutsionalnyi i elektoralnyi krizisy v period demokraticheskogo tranzita (Veimarskaya respublika, 1919–1933 gg.)]. Political expertise [Politicheskaya ekspertiza: POLITEKS], no. 2, pp. 211–212. (In Russian.)
  • Yanov А. (1995). After Yeltsin. «Weimar» Russia [Posle Yeltsina. Veimarskaya Rossiya]. Moscow: KRUK Publ, 320 p. (In Russian.)
  • Zhenin I. (2013). Why did the Weimar Republic lasted only 14 years? [Pochemu Veimarskaya respublika proderzhalas vsego 14 let? PostScience [PostNauka], November 17 (http://postnauka.ru/video/19574). (In Russian.)
  • Deutsches Historisches Museum (2014). Weimarer Republik: Industrie und Wirtschaft (https://www.dhm.de/lemo/kapitel/weimarer-republik/industrie-und-wirtschaft.html).
  • Planète-UMP (undated). Le Directoir http://www.planete-ump.fr/t24968-Le-Directoire-1795-1799.htm).
  • World History at KMLA (2004). History of France. France: The Directory, 1795–1799: the Economy (http://www.zum.de/whkmla/region/france/france17951799ec.html).
Publisher: Southern Federal University
Founder: Southern Federal University
ISSN: 2073-6606